Yes, criminal charges in Ohio can be dropped or dismissed before your case reaches trial. Only the prosecutor can drop charges and only the judge can dismiss them, so an alleged victim cannot drop charges on their own. The most common reasons are weak evidence, evidence that gets suppressed, a completed diversion program, and missed deadlines.
Facing criminal charges in Ohio can be an overwhelming and anxiety-inducing experience. The uncertainty of the outcome, the potential consequences if convicted, and the daunting task of clearing your name can cast a long shadow. But this is when you should contact an experienced Columbus criminal defense attorney.
No one should be forced to accept an unjust conviction or fall victim to unwarranted charges. There is a lot a lawyer can do to help your case, up to and including getting your case dismissed or charges dropped.
How to Get Charges Dropped or Dismissed in Ohio
At Luftman, Heck & Associates, we pride ourselves on our record of helping clients overcome their legal challenges. Our Columbus defense lawyers have helped many clients get their criminal charges dismissed, reduced, and proven innocent.
Here are seven ways your attorney may be able to accomplish this goal for you.
1. Show a Lack of Probable Cause
For an arrest to be lawful, the police must have more than just a hunch or suspicion; they require concrete, objective facts that reasonably suggest your involvement in a crime. This requirement is called “probable cause,” and it’s a safeguard against arbitrary arrests, ensuring that there’s a substantial basis for the allegations against you.
A Probable Cause Example
Imagine a scenario where a hit-and-run on Morse Road in Columbus, and a witness describes the offending vehicle as a red four-door sedan. If you happen to drive a similar car, this could lead the police to suspect your involvement, constituting probable cause.
But, if you own a black sports car, your vehicle bears no resemblance to the one described. In this instance, stopping and arresting you for the hit-and-run lacks probable cause. This discrepancy forms the basis for challenging the legality of your arrest.
How Lawyers Demonstrate a Lack of Probable Cause
In such situations, it may seem easy to just explain to the police that you drive a different car. But your criminal defense attorney plays a crucial role. They can meticulously review the circumstances of your arrest, scrutinizing the facts and evidence, or lack thereof, to determine if probable cause was genuinely present.
Once they can legally deconstruct the situation and demonstrate how it was based on insufficient grounds. This may require vigorously arguing the point in court, but if successful, you could have the charges against you dismissed.
Does Probable Cause Apply?
The infographic below shows how an attorney tests for probable cause: reviewing the initial incident and evidence, gathering more evidence, scrutinizing the facts, and looking for discrepancies.
2. Is There Enough Evidence?
A fundamental principle of our justice system ensures that you are presumed innocent until proven guilty of a crime. So, to secure your conviction in a criminal case, prosecutors must present sufficient evidence to support the allegation that you committed the crime. This evidence must be compelling enough to convince a grand jury or a judge that there’s a reasonable basis to proceed with the charges.
A Case of Insufficient Evidence
Consider a case where you are accused of theft. The prosecution alleges that you stole items from a store, but they have only circumstantial evidence, such as your presence near the store around the time of the incident. However, there’s no direct evidence linking you to the crime – no surveillance footage, eyewitness testimony, or physical evidence. In such a situation, the lack of concrete evidence can lead to the dismissal of charges, as the prosecution does not meet the burden of proof.
Scrutinizing Evidence Can Be Hard
Not everyone has the legal training to determine if specific legal standards are met – except skilled attorneys. A criminal defense attorney can review all the evidence to identify weaknesses and gaps. By highlighting the insufficiency or unreliability of certain key pieces of evidence, your attorney is in a much better position to get charges dismissed or dropped.
Evidence Types in Criminal Cases
The three types of evidence in a criminal case are physical, testimonial, and circumstantial, and your attorney can challenge each one for reliability and relevance.
3. The Search Was Illegal
The right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures is guaranteed in the Constitution. Police can only search you, your vehicle, or your residence under specific conditions. These conditions are grounded in the necessity of having a reasonable belief, or probable cause, that you have been involved in criminal activity. Searches based on discriminatory factors like race, gender, religion, or mere suspicions are not legally justified.
Illegal Searches Are Not Uncommon
Imagine a scenario where the police come to your house, enter, and search your home without a warrant, alleging drug possession. However, no evidence of drug-related activity, such as recent informant tips or suspicious behavior, was present before the search. While in the house, they noticed a prescription medication that wasn’t issued to you. In this case, the initial search lacks legal standing and would likely be considered an invasion of your privacy rights.
Spotting an Illegal Search
Aside from the absence of a warrant, in cases of illegal searches, it can be difficult for an average citizen to examine the circumstances to determine if a search was conducted lawfully. But if your attorney assesses the matter and the search is illegal, they can argue for suppressing any evidence obtained. This can often lead to the dismissal of charges, as the prosecution’s case may be significantly weakened without the evidence gathered from the unlawful search.
A Search Legality Checklist
Signs of an illegal search include no warrant or an invalid warrant, no explicit consent, no probable cause, a search that went beyond the scope of the warrant, and a violation of your right to privacy.
4. Prosecutor Discretion
You might be surprised to learn that prosecuting attorneys can dismiss certain charges.
Factors in a Prosecutor’s Decision to Dismiss
- The Nature of the Charges: Minor offenses are more likely to be dismissed, especially when compared to more serious allegations.
- Your Criminal Record: Individuals with no prior criminal record, or a very minimal one, stand a better chance of having their charges dismissed.
- The Victim’s Stance: In cases where the victim may find testifying too traumatic or damaging, the prosecutor might dismiss the charges, respecting the victim’s mental and emotional well-being.
Prosecutorial Discretion in Action
Suppose you’re facing a minor trespassing charge and have no prior criminal record. Your defense attorney might approach the prosecutor, highlighting your clean history and the minor nature of the offense. They could negotiate terms involving community service or a diversion program instead of prosecution. In such cases, prosecutors often agree to dismiss charges, considering it an equitable resolution.
5. There are Jurisdictional Issues
Jurisdiction refers to the authority granted to a court to hear a case and make legal decisions. So, there are certain situations where the state’s prosecutor may not have the right to listen to your case, including federal prosecutors who lack the jurisdiction to do so. Federal and state courts are different. If your case is heard in a court without proper jurisdiction, your charges could be dismissed or your conviction overturned.
How Boundary Issues Can End in Dismissal
Consider that you are charged in one Ohio county with an offense that allegedly took place entirely in another county. A case filed in the wrong county or the wrong court is filed in the wrong venue, and your attorney can move to have it dismissed. The same principle separates the two court systems: state and federal courts hear different kinds of cases, and a prosecutor cannot pursue a charge in a court that has no authority over it.
Your Lawyer Can Point Out Jurisdiction Issues
A defense attorney will examine the specifics of your case to determine the appropriate jurisdiction. This includes analyzing the nature of the alleged crime, where it was committed, and other jurisdictional markers. If they discover that the case has been improperly filed in the wrong court, they will move to have it dismissed.
Jurisdictional Authority in Ohio
Some offenses fall under state jurisdiction, some under federal jurisdiction, and some under both, which is called concurrent jurisdiction.
6. Diversion and Intervention Programs
Some cases end in dismissal without a fight over the evidence. Ohio prosecutors and courts offer pretrial diversion programs that let a defendant complete conditions such as classes, community service, or restitution, after which the charge can be dismissed; Ohio’s theft diversion program is one example. Intervention in Lieu of Conviction under ORC 2951.041 works in a similar way: the court pauses the case while the defendant completes a treatment plan, and successful completion can end in dismissal. Our attorneys can tell you whether one of these programs fits your situation.
7. The State Missed a Speedy Trial Deadline
Ohio’s speedy trial statute, ORC 2945.71, sets deadlines for bringing a criminal case to trial. The deadlines are counted in days and depend on the level of the charge. For example, a first- or second-degree misdemeanor must be brought to trial within 90 days and a felony within 270 days, and each day you spend in jail on the charge counts as three. If the State misses its deadline and the time was not properly extended, your attorney can move to have the charges dismissed.
There’s a Difference: Dismissed vs. Dropped Charges
While both dismissed or dropped charges are desirable, there is a distinction.
Charges can be dropped at any point by the prosecutor after you are arrested. Dropped charges usually indicate that the prosecution does not feel they can get a guilty verdict. Should the prosecutor file charges but a judge determines insufficient evidence at the preliminary hearing, the judge may dismiss the charges.
Judges cannot drop charges, but they can dismiss them.
Can the Victim Drop the Charges in Ohio?
No. Once a charge is filed in Ohio, the case belongs to the State, and the prosecutor decides whether it goes forward. An alleged victim can tell the prosecutor they do not want to proceed, and that can carry weight, but the prosecutor can still pursue the case without their cooperation. This question comes up most often in domestic violence cases, and the answer is the same: the State, not the alleged victim, decides.
Frequently Asked Questions About Dropped and Dismissed Charges in Ohio
Can charges be dropped before a court date in Ohio?
Yes. The prosecutor can drop charges before your first court date or at any point before trial, and the judge can dismiss the case before trial, usually after a defense motion. Each of the seven reasons above, from a lack of probable cause to a completed diversion program, can lead to that result.
How long does a prosecutor have to file charges?
Ohio sets a statute of limitations for each level of offense, so the filing deadline depends on how serious the charge is. A charge filed after that period has run can be dismissed. Once a charge is filed, the separate speedy trial deadline described in way 7 above applies.
Can the victim drop charges?
No. The State brings the charge, so the prosecutor alone decides whether to drop it. The alleged victim can ask the prosecutor not to go forward, and prosecutors do consider that request, but it is not the final word.
What is the difference between dropped and dismissed?
Dropped means the prosecutor chose not to pursue the charge. Dismissed means the judge ended the case, usually on a motion from the defense or because the evidence did not hold up. In both situations the case ends without a conviction.
Does a dismissed charge stay on my record?
A dismissed charge is not a conviction, but the arrest and the court case can still appear on background checks until the record is sealed or expunged. Our attorneys can review whether your dismissed case qualifies for record sealing or expungement in Ohio.
Results
Disorderly Conduct Dismissed in Madison County
Disorderly conduct is a common charge in Ohio, and it can arise in any number of situations. However, as a misdemeanor, a conviction still carries significant penalties. It also creates a mark on your permanent criminal record.
As a result, when a client recently contacted LHA about being charged with disorderly conduct in Madison County, we worked to ensure the situation did not cause him too much hassle. Luftman, Heck & Associates reviewed the facts and immediately began discussing the details with the prosecutor.
By highlighting the flaws in the case, attorney Scranton negotiated to have the disorderly conduct charge completely dismissed. This was as good a result as it gets because it kept a misdemeanor off of his record and let him put the whole thing behind him.
London Theft Case Dismissed
Such was the case for an individual in London, who recently found themselves in trouble when they were charged with a theft offense. Wanting to avoid a conviction for the crime, they reached out to Luftman, Heck & Associates for help.
We immediately got to work on the case. Due to his quick involvement, swift action, and aggressive defense skills, the client’s case was dismissed.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome in your case. Individual results may vary based on the facts, injuries, jurisdiction, venue, witnesses, parties, and other factors. The results and client testimonials provided are not necessarily representative of the results obtained by all clients or their satisfaction with the firm’s services.
You can find more criminal defense case results from Luftman, Heck & Associates.
Contact LHA for Help Getting Charges Dropped or Dismissed
You don’t have to spend your days terrified of your future. The Columbus criminal defense lawyers at Luftman, Heck & Associates may be able to get your charges dismissed, dropped, or reduced.
We’ve helped countless people in situations like yours. Let us look at what our legal team can do for you.
Call (614) 500-3836 for a no-cost, risk-free case evaluation today, or use our contact form.