Ohio DUI Defense: 7 Signs the DUI Case Against You Is Weak

If you were arrested for OVI in Columbus, Ohio, you may think your fate is sealed, but not all DUI cases result in conviction or are poised for a reduced outcome. From unlawful stops to faulty tests, many are built on shaky ground.

The earlier you recognize the clear signs that a DUI case may be too weak to hold up in court, the better your chances. At Luftman, Heck & Associates, our Columbus DUI defense lawyers have helped countless people in situations like yours challenge questionable DUI arrests and flawed evidence. Contact LHA today for a free DUI case evaluation at (614) 500-3836 or submit the details online.

What Makes a DUI Case Weak in Ohio?

Being charged with a DUI or OVI (Operating a Vehicle Impaired) in Ohio is always serious but remember this key legal truth: The prosecution must prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

If the evidence is flawed, missing, or obtained unlawfully, your DUI case may not be strong enough to hold up in court.

The Burden Is on the State in an OVI Case

In any criminal case — including DUI — the burden of proof lies squarely on the government. Prosecutors must demonstrate, with legally admissible evidence, that:

You were operating a vehicle in Ohio,
You were impaired at the time of operation,
That all procedures leading to your arrest complied with your constitutional rights.

If the prosecution fails to establish these elements, the OVI charges against you may be thrown out or significantly reduced.

While Ohio prosecutors are under pressure to secure DUI convictions, many cases rely on evidence that doesn’t meet legal standards. That’s where an experienced DUI defense attorney makes a difference. By identifying procedural missteps, questioning unreliable DUI test results, and holding law enforcement accountable, we can often get DUI charges reduced, dismissed, or beaten in court.

Related Reading:

The Signs a Columbus DUI Case Is Weaker Than You Think

1. You Were Stopped Without Probable Cause

Imagine you’re driving home through the Short North after dinner with friends. You’re under the speed limit, using your turn signal — doing everything right. Suddenly, you see flashing lights. The officer says he stopped you because you “looked suspicious.”

That’s not a lawful reason to initiate a traffic stop.

In Ohio, police need reasonable suspicion to pull you over, which could be a traffic violation, swerving, or something that suggests you’re impaired. To arrest you for OVI, they must later establish probable cause according to Ohio Revised Code § 4511.19. If they can’t justify the stop with clear evidence, your attorney can file a motion to suppress all the evidence that followed, including field sobriety tests and breath results.

2. The Field Sobriety Test Was Improper

Let’s say the officer asked you to do a one-leg stand test on a cracked sidewalk in downtown Columbus in the rain, with traffic rushing by. You’re nervous, wearing boots, and don’t fully understand the instructions. You stumble once, and the officer says you failed.

Field sobriety tests (FSTs) are standardized under NHTSA guidelines. Officers must follow strict procedures, give clear instructions, and ensure the environment is safe and appropriate. Medical conditions, anxiety, poor lighting, or uneven surfaces can easily affect your performance and make the results misleading.

3. The Breath or Blood Test Results Are Unreliable

In Ohio, breath tests are the most common chemical tests used in DUI cases, often administered at the roadside or back at the station. Blood tests are typically used when you’re taken to a hospital after a crash or are unable or unwilling to perform a breath test. Under Ohio’s implied consent law, refusing either test can result in an automatic license suspension — but that doesn’t make the test results infallible.

Both breath and blood tests used in DUI cases rely on strict procedures to ensure accuracy — but those procedures aren’t always followed perfectly.

For breath tests, the device must be calibrated appropriately, operated by certified personnel, and preceded by a 20-minute observation period to avoid contamination from things like burping, smoking, or mouthwash.
For blood tests, the sample must be drawn in a sterile environment, securely stored and transported, and documented through a clear chain of custody.

Even when procedures are followed, factors like acid reflux (GERD), diabetes, or dental work can cause falsely high breath readings. Blood samples can also degrade or become contaminated if mishandled, creating serious doubt about the reliability of the results.

If your chemical test wasn’t done by the book — or if there’s any question about its accuracy — your attorney can challenge its validity. Without solid test results, the prosecution’s case against you may weaken significantly.

Related Reading:

4. The Blood or Urine Samples Were Mishandled

Let’s say you were taken to a Columbus-area hospital after your arrest and submitted to a blood or urine test. While your initial OVI charges may be for a high BAC DUI, weeks later, your attorney could obtain lab records and discover that the sample wasn’t properly sealed, stored at the wrong temperature, or changed hands multiple times without clear documentation of who handled it and when.

That’s a chain of custody issue.

In Ohio DUI cases, blood and urine samples must be collected, transported, tested, and stored according to strict forensic standards. Every person who handles your sample must be accounted for in writing, and every step in the process must follow standardized procedures to preserve the integrity of the evidence.

When this chain of custody is broken, even briefly, it opens the door for contamination, tampering, degradation, or misidentification. For example:

Improper refrigeration can alter BAC readings.
Unsealed containers may allow evaporation or contamination.
Lack of documentation raises doubts about whether the sample even belongs to you.

If the prosecution can’t prove your sample was collected and tested correctly, a skilled DUI defense attorney can move to have the results excluded. Without that chemical proof of impairment, the case against you may be reduced to a lesser tier DUI or outright dismissed.

Related Reading:

5. The Bodycam or Dashcam Doesn’t Match the Report

It’s certainly telling when what’s captured on bodycam or dashcam footage doesn’t align with what an officer writes in their report in a DUI case. When these discrepancies arise, it can throw a wrench in the prosecution’s case.

Suppose an officer pulls you over for swerving on I-270, and you’re subsequently charged with OVI. In their report, they might detail that your speech was slurred speech, you were unsteady on your feet, and you exhibited a strong odor of alcohol. However, when the bodycam footage is reviewed, it might tell a different story.

Perhaps the video shows you speaking clearly and maintaining your balance relatively well (considering the roadside conditions). And while there might be a faint odor, it could be attributed to a passenger you were giving a ride home.

These inconsistencies create reasonable doubt, and a defense attorney can use conflicting evidence to argue that the officer’s observations and conclusions in the report might be exaggerated, inaccurate, or even biased.

Related Reading:

6. Your Rights Were Violated During the Arrest

If you were taken into custody and the officer never read your Miranda rights — or continued questioning you after you asked for a lawyer — that’s a serious violation of your constitutional protections. Any statements you made during that time, even admissions, may be inadmissible in court. In Ohio DUI cases, officers must clearly explain the state’s implied consent law when requesting a breath or blood test. If that advisement was skipped or unclear, it may be grounds to challenge your test results or license suspension.

These rights aren’t just technicalities but a critical part of your defense. If your attorney can prove your rights were ignored, a judge may suppress key evidence, weakening the prosecution’s case and potentially leading to a dismissal or reduced charges.

Related Reading:

7. You Were Stopped at an Improper DUI Checkpoint

DUI checkpoints are legal in Ohio, but only if they follow strict rules: advance public notice, a neutral system for stopping cars, and clear signage and procedures. If you were pulled over at a checkpoint on I-70 or Broad Street without seeing warning signs or clear guidelines being followed the stop — and everything that came after — could be considered unconstitutional.

An unlawful checkpoint can result in all collected evidence being thrown out, including test results or officer observations. In many cases, if there’s no other valid reason for the stop, this can lead to a complete dismissal of your DUI charges

Related Reading:

Don’t Assume Your DUI Is Open and Shut

Even if you think the evidence against you is strong, that doesn’t mean your case is beyond saving. Many DUI charges in Columbus are built on weak foundations: mishandled evidence, unlawful stops, or constitutional violations. At Luftman, Heck & Associates, our experienced DUI lawyers know how to uncover and use those flaws for your benefit.

Review Our Successful DUI/OVI Cases

Related Reading:

If You Suspect Your DUI Case Is Weak, Call LHA

At Luftman, Heck & Associates, we understand how overwhelming an OVI can feel, especially if you’re unsure whether to fight it, negotiate, or push for dismissal. But you don’t have to figure it out alone. If you think the case against you might not hold up, let’s talk.

Call (614) 500-3836 or request your free consultation here. We’ll review your situation, explain your options, and help you take the best next step.

Ohio DUI Defense: 7 Signs the DUI Case Against You Is Weak

What Makes a DUI Case Weak in Ohio?

The Burden Is on the State in an OVI Case

The Signs a Columbus DUI Case Is Weaker Than You Think

1. You Were Stopped Without Probable Cause

2. The Field Sobriety Test Was Improper

3. The Breath or Blood Test Results Are Unreliable

4. The Blood or Urine Samples Were Mishandled

5. The Bodycam or Dashcam Doesn’t Match the Report

6. Your Rights Were Violated During the Arrest

7. You Were Stopped at an Improper DUI Checkpoint

Don’t Assume Your DUI Is Open and Shut

If You Suspect Your DUI Case Is Weak, Call LHA

If you have been charged with a crime, contact us TODAY for a FREE consultation

Practice Areas

Attorneys