If you’ve been pulled over in Columbus and are facing an OVI (Operating a Vehicle Impaired) charge, your next steps can determine whether you will receive a reduced penalty or face jail, fines, and a long license suspension.
At Luftman, Heck & Associates LLP, our Columbus DUI defense attorneys have handled thousands of drunk and drugged driving cases in Franklin County. We understand Ohio’s 2025 OVI laws inside and out, including recent updates under House Bill 37 (HB 37), and have a reputation for protecting drivers’ rights.
Call (614) 500-3836 or submit the details of your case 24/7 for a free OVI case evaluation.
Common DUI Mistakes that Can Make Your Case Worse
This guide outlines the 12 most common mistakes drivers make during and after an OVI stop in Columbus. Whether you’re a student near OSU, a nurse commuting through the Short North, or a CDL holder pulled over on I-70, avoiding these errors can dramatically improve your chances.
1. Talking Too Much at the Traffic Stop
Under your Fifth Amendment rights, you’re never required to answer questions that could incriminate you. The moment an officer asks, “Have you been drinking tonight?” your best response is a polite but firm, “I’d prefer not to answer without legal counsel.”
Admitting to even to “just a couple of drinks” or explaining you’re tired from work can still be used as evidence to justify field sobriety tests, detainment, or arrest.
Many drivers mistakenly try to talk their way out of trouble, thinking cooperation means leniency. In fact, unsolicited information often arms the prosecution. Columbus police officers are trained to detect signs of impairment based on speech, answers, and behavior. Even casual remarks can be twisted in court.
The smart approach is to keep your hands visible, present ID when requested, and say as little as possible.
Read DUI Checkpoints in Ohio & 5 Tips if You’re Stopped
2. Performing Field Sobriety or Oral Fluid Tests
Ohio law allows officers to request oral fluid swab testing at the roadside, thanks to HB 37. These tests detect the presence of drugs, not impairment levels. Refusing these roadside tests does not carry the same penalties as refusing an evidentiary chemical test, so it’s generally wise to decline. Politely say, “I’m not comfortable taking roadside tests,” and remain calm.
The same logic applies to field sobriety tests like walking a straight line or standing on one foot. These are designed to gather probable cause, not determine your innocence. They’re often conducted under poor conditions, like on uneven pavement, among flashing lights, or under intense anxiety. Officers rarely “pass” drivers, and bodycam footage can make you look impaired even when you’re not.
Read 5 Ways Lawyers Get OVI Tests Thrown Out
3. Driving a “Pull-Me-Over” Car
Police need a reason to initiate a traffic stop, and minor equipment violations provide an easy excuse. In Columbus, officers routinely scan for expired registration stickers, cracked taillights, and license plate lights. If your car has visible defects or you’re driving erratically (even too slowly), you’re painting a target on your back.
This is especially risky in areas with heavy OVI enforcement, like the Arena District or near campus on High Street. Driving with a suspended license or under vehicle forfeiture orders (common after past OVI convictions) can quickly escalate a routine stop into a criminal charge.
Keeping your car maintained and paperwork current are among your best OVI defenses is avoiding the stop in the first place.
4. Being Combative or Disrespectful
Every interaction with law enforcement is now captured on body-worn cameras in Columbus. If you become aggressive, sarcastic, or visibly agitated, that footage can and will be used against you. Prosecutors often cite a driver’s demeanor as evidence of impairment. That can mean arguing that your slurred speech, erratic behavior, or combative tone reflects intoxication.
Moreover, officers have discretion during an arrest. If you’re polite and non-confrontational, you may avoid charges like obstruction or resisting. But your chances of a favorable OVI plea can vanish if you’re belligerent, even verbally. Judges in Franklin County Municipal Court don’t look kindly on defendants who curse at officers during arrest. Show respect—even if you’re scared or frustrated.
Read: 5 Things To Do When A Police Officer Pulls You Over in Ohio
5. Trying to Handle the Case Yourself
Defending an OVI charge in Ohio is complex. The stakes include mandatory jail time, thousands in fines, a license suspension, higher insurance premiums, and for many a threat to professional licensing.
Still, some people try to represent themselves, thinking they can “explain what happened.”
Experienced Columbus OVI lawyers know how to challenge field sobriety results, dispute test reliability (including the new oral swabs), and suppress unlawfully gathered evidence. They also know which judges are more receptive to intervention programs, limited driving privileges, or reduced charges. Without counsel, you’re risking permanent consequences.
Read The Cost of a DUI in Columbus, Ohio & How a Lawyer Saves You Money
6. Missing the 30-Day ALS Appeal Deadline
When you’re arrested for OVI in Ohio, the Bureau of Motor Vehicles (BMV) will automatically suspend your license unless you act fast. You generally have 30 days, or sometimes as little as 20 days to request an ALS hearing. Miss this window, and the suspension becomes final, even if your OVI case is later dismissed.
Many drivers think the court will address this automatically. Not so. The ALS (Administrative License Suspension) process is separate from your criminal case. An experienced lawyer can request a hearing, challenge the suspension, and potentially get your license back sooner. But once the deadline passes, your hands are tied.
7. Driving Before Your Limited Privileges Begin
Franklin County courts often approve limited driving privileges during an OVI suspension—for work, school, or medical needs. But there’s a catch: you must wait out a hard suspension period (usually 15 days for low-tier offenses, 30 for test refusals). Driving before privileges are granted is a first-degree misdemeanor and makes your legal situation far worse.
Many drivers get caught in this trap by assuming their lawyer filed for privileges or that “it’s probably fine.” Columbus police are particularly alert for suspended drivers, especially during court or probation check-ins. Wait until the court order is signed, filed, and received before getting behind the wheel.
8. Ignoring Ignition Interlock or “Party Plate” Rules
Under HB 37, Ohio judges must impose ignition interlock devices (IIDs) for many second-time offenders and may require them for first-time drivers seeking unlimited privileges. Some Franklin County judges also mandate the “party plates” (red-on-yellow license plates), signaling restricted driving status.
Tampering with an interlock, failing calibration checks, or driving a non-equipped vehicle can lead to new criminal charges and vehicle immobilization. Skipping party plates can violate the terms of your privileges and make your car a target for law enforcement.
9. Posting About Your Arrest on Social Media
Columbus prosecutors monitor TikTok, Threads, Instagram, and Facebook for posts by OVI defendants. A single clip of you laughing about your arrest, showing a breathalyzer, or mocking police can damage your credibility and undermine legal defenses like lack of probable cause or test error.
Even if your account is private, screenshots can spread. Better yet, take down recent posts and lock your social media accounts during your case.
10. Waiting Too Long to Preserve Body Cam Footage
While Columbus PD typically stores body-worn and dash cam video for two years, that footage isn’t always easy to access later. If your attorney doesn’t send a preservation letter quickly, the footage might be overwritten or subject to new public-records fees imposed by the city.
This video can make or break your case. It may reveal testing protocol errors, faulty instructions, or your calm demeanor, which are details that may contradict the officer’s written report.
11. Declining an Independent Blood Test
Under Ohio Revised Code § 4511.19, you’re entitled to request an independent chemical test—typically a blood draw—after the state conducts its own test. This can be a game-changer if the state used a roadside oral swab, which only shows drug presence rather than levels.
An independent test from a hospital or lab provides a timestamped, defensible BAC or drug level. It may contradict the state’s findings or show your BAC was still rising at the time. Tell your lawyer or ask for one immediately after your test.
12. Accepting an Offer Without an OVI Lawyer
Franklin County prosecutors often begin with “standard” plea offers: fines, a short suspension, maybe a weekend program. But these don’t always account for your full situation, especially if you’re eligible for intervention programs, CDL protection, or have test suppression arguments.
A seasoned Columbus DUI lawyer knows which judges are open to alternative sentencing, no-party-plate deals, or reduced charges for first offenders. They also understand nuances in test machine maintenance records, officer conduct, and field protocol errors. Don’t settle for the first offer. Get a second opinion.
Read: Ohio DUI Defense: 7 Signs the DUI Case Against You Is Weak
Ohio OVI Penalties at a Glance
| Offense | Jail Time | Fine | License Suspension | Interlock |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st (Tier 1) | 3 days (or D.I.P.) | $375–$1,075 | 1 year | Possible for unlimited privileges |
| 2nd (within 10 yrs) | 10–20 days | $525–$1,625 | 1–5 years | Mandatory |
| 3rd+ | Up to 1 year | $850–$2,750 | 2–10 years | Mandatory |
| Test Refusal | Additional 1-year ALS | N/A | Add-on suspension | May impact plea options |
- Read Frequently Asked Questions About OVIs & DUIs in Columbus, OH
- Read The Essential Guide for First-Time DUI Offenders in Columbus, OH
Get a Proven OVI Defense Attorney Today
An OVI in Columbus is serious, but it doesn’t have to derail your life. The most important decision you make isn’t what happened during the stop—it’s what you do next. By avoiding common mistakes and acting fast, you give yourself the best chance to protect your record, your license, and your freedom.
At Luftman, Heck & Associates LLP, our DUI attorneys understand Ohio’s OVI laws, the tendencies of Franklin County judges in OVI cases, and the strategies local prosecutors use – even in municipalities like Dublin, Westerville, Upper Arlington, Worthington, and more. We’ve helped thousands of drivers across Central Ohio with skill, discretion, and results. Call us now at (614) 500-3836 or schedule your free case review online.
Call Now (614) 500-3836